Pomp and Circumcision
Yesterday, my 8-day-old nephew Noah had a rough day. First he had a doctor's appointment in the morning, and then Noah had his bris in the evening, which my partner and I hosted at our house. Noah's parents -- my brother and his fiance -- were there, as well as my mom and dad, the rabbi, and the mohel. We spent the afternoon putting together the house, getting the snacks set up, and talking. It was all so exciting, Noah promptly fell asleep.
The mohel showed up at around 4:30 pm, give or take, and while we waited for the rabbi to arrive, he went over post-operation care with Noah's parents. The rabbi arrived at a little after 5:00. I had the honor of holding Noah's legs still during the circumcision, which meant that I got the closest view. It was both amazing and beautiful on the one hand, and horrifying on the other.
Every man in the room felt some sypathetic pain there I think. At one point, the mohel had what appeared to be a pair of scissors in his hand, and that's when I just looked at Noah's face and tried to calm him down and comfort him. But I did see part of the circumcision. I mean, I was holding Noah's legs, how could I not? And let me tell you, I'm still occasionally twitching from the memory of yesterday..
But on the other hand, it is truly a beautiful and quintessentially Jewish ceremony. We're welcoming Noah into our family and the Jewish community. And that is a very happy occasion. Why is it done? Because of this passage in Genesis (17:1-14):
Noah recovered amazingly quickly. During the ritual he wailed like a banshee, but immediately after when his mother picked him up, he quieted down. There was an anesthetic applied and the mohel assured us he didn't feel pain, just pressure, and that he was just cold and uncomfortable. That's hard to imagine of course, but I guess he does this all the time so he would know.
During the baby naming that followed, a number of us teared up as the rabbi spoke. And Noah received as his Hebrew name Yosef, after my grandfather. Afterward, we gnoshed on fruit salad, challah, kugel, and cookies.
It was a taxing emotional experience, definitely. But beautiful. I offer my congratulations again to Noah's mom and dad. He's a beautiful, perfect baby, and we're so happy to have him as part of the family!
One interesting, amusing thing, the mohel's name sounded like "Max Mince"... I think it was actually "Mintz". But still...
The mohel showed up at around 4:30 pm, give or take, and while we waited for the rabbi to arrive, he went over post-operation care with Noah's parents. The rabbi arrived at a little after 5:00. I had the honor of holding Noah's legs still during the circumcision, which meant that I got the closest view. It was both amazing and beautiful on the one hand, and horrifying on the other.
Every man in the room felt some sypathetic pain there I think. At one point, the mohel had what appeared to be a pair of scissors in his hand, and that's when I just looked at Noah's face and tried to calm him down and comfort him. But I did see part of the circumcision. I mean, I was holding Noah's legs, how could I not? And let me tell you, I'm still occasionally twitching from the memory of yesterday..
But on the other hand, it is truly a beautiful and quintessentially Jewish ceremony. We're welcoming Noah into our family and the Jewish community. And that is a very happy occasion. Why is it done? Because of this passage in Genesis (17:1-14):
"Throughout all generations, every male shall be circumcised when he is eight days old...This shall be my covenant in your flesh, an eternal covenant. The uncircumcised male whose foreskin has not been circumcised, shall have his soul cut off from his people; he has broken my Covenant."
Noah recovered amazingly quickly. During the ritual he wailed like a banshee, but immediately after when his mother picked him up, he quieted down. There was an anesthetic applied and the mohel assured us he didn't feel pain, just pressure, and that he was just cold and uncomfortable. That's hard to imagine of course, but I guess he does this all the time so he would know.
During the baby naming that followed, a number of us teared up as the rabbi spoke. And Noah received as his Hebrew name Yosef, after my grandfather. Afterward, we gnoshed on fruit salad, challah, kugel, and cookies.
It was a taxing emotional experience, definitely. But beautiful. I offer my congratulations again to Noah's mom and dad. He's a beautiful, perfect baby, and we're so happy to have him as part of the family!
One interesting, amusing thing, the mohel's name sounded like "Max Mince"... I think it was actually "Mintz". But still...


7 Comments:
Beautifully retold. Thanks for not going into too much detail about the procedure. I don't know if I believe he just felt cold and pressure. It sure didn't sound that way.
Yeah, I wasn't about to subject everyone in the blogosphere to a graphic description of the procedure. Besides, writing it would bring back too many vivid memories...
Sadly the "quietening down" was in fact traumatic shock. Genital mutilation is everything you intuitively sensed it was.
Is that your professional medical diagnosis? I don't remember seeing you there Senator Frist...
It's very comforting (and refreshing!) to read such a beautiful account of a very meaningful ceremony. Especially after constantly reading nothing but bashing and attacks even from fellow Jews who obviously are very ignorant about the meaning and importance of the brit milah and are influenced by secular ideas. Kudos to you!
I am not anti-Jewish, but 110% anti-circumcision. It's wrong and no words in the Torah or Bible justify it. Harming children, for any reason, is wrong. And circumcision harms children. Period.
If we were to do everything demanded of 'us' in the Torah or Christian bible, we'd be taking eyes, teeth, etc.
Come on people, leave the little boy's privates intact and don't mutilate them because you were mutilated, your father was mutilated, etc.
I am not Jewish. I was circumcised. I am sickened and horrified that this stupid, barbaric activity continues, for religious reasons, monetary reason, customs, etc. There is NO justification for it. It's wrong. Period. Check out this website.
www.norm.org
To set the record straight, the baby recieved dorsal nerve block anesthesia. He did not faint - that is, go into neurogenic shock (though that happens commonly when a circumcision is done without anesthetizing the penis). He was awake and alert (and happy) once he was picked up. I won't speak for Christians, but the Jewish interpretation of the Torah (from ancient, biblical times) does not allow the taking of eyes or teeth or of any other body part in revenge for damaging any part of another person's body. It is an interesting fact that a disproportionally high percentage of Nobel prize winners were ritually circumcised as infants - so the procedure does not seem to have long-lasting negative effects. Jews believe God ordered this procedure as an eternal sign of the covenant they have with Him. You don't have to believe this. But, in the absence of proof that the procedure is truly injurious (the opposite appears to be the case), it would be very civil of circumcision opponents to respect the right of anyone who does believe in that covenant to act accordingly.
Dr. Mintz
Post a Comment
<< Home